Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by guzik 224 days ago
Congrats guys on your release. I tried new VitalLens side by side with my medical grade tracker (Aidmed One) but the respiration numbers were quite off.

Curious if you've done any comparisons against actual hardware (chest-based or contact PPG), or if validation is mostly dataset based for now.

1 comments

Thanks! Curious under what circumstances the respiration was off - were you standing or sitting down? I can usually see the resp wave go up and down as I breathe while sitting down.

I have written up a technical report on the validation here: https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.27028 This validation is based on several datasets, which all have gold standard ground truth from contact PPG and RESP from chest straps and/or impedance pneumography (from ECG)