Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ViewTrick1002 219 days ago
Ignore everything that makes the 737 a modern passenger aircraft and it’s awesome!
1 comments

> Ignore everything that makes the 737 a modern passenger aircraft and it’s awesome!

You’re moving the goalposts because you didn’t understand what an airframe is.

The engine anti ice system are literally generic aerodynamic parts and control systems provided by Boeing.

You know, part of the same assembly causing MCAS to exist.

But that is of course not part of the airframe.

> that is of course not part of the airframe

Correct.

The 737’s airframe’s excellence is the reason Boeing was loath to let it go. It’s a really good airframe, and a market fit to boot for the transition from hub and spoke. A clean-sheet design for the 737 would look a lot like the 737. That is what makes the shortcuts tempting.

Engines, avionics and control software are distinct components and not part of the airframe. (Debatable only on engine cowlings and mounts. Neither of which were relevant to the 737 Max’s faults.)