[BobbyTables2]

What pisses me off is that the “brutalist” style in the 1990s was arguably perfect. Having standardized persistent menus, meaningful compact toolbars was nice.

Then the world threw away the menus, adopted an idiotic “ribbon” that uses more screen real estate. Unsatisfied, we dumbed down desktop apps to look like mobile apps, even though input technology remains different.

Websites also decided to avoid blue underlined text for links and be as nonstandard as possible.

Frankly, developers did UI better before UI designers went off the deep end.

[zeroc8]

The brutalist style also meant that I didn't need a UI designer for my applications. With Delphi I was able to create great apps in a matter of days. And users loved them, because they were so snappy and well thought out. Nowadays it seems I need a UI designer to accomplish just about anything. And the resulting apps might look better but are worse when you are actually trying to accomplish work using them.

[DrewADesign]

Actual interface designers communicate functionality and state through an interface. If your designer is designing interfaces that look good but are less functional for the intended user base, you’ve hired a graphic designer that claims to be an interface designer. It’s not a problem you can generalize to design or designers any more than someone can generalize that web developers suck because the ones they hire to build a serious web app are really Wordpress plugin hacks that don’t even realize they aren’t web developers.

[sjamaan]

I was ranting exactly the same just yesterday. Nowadays UI designers seem to have forgotten all about affordances. Back in the day you had drop shadows below buttons to indicate that they could be pressed, big chunky scrollbars with two lines on the handle to indicate "grippiness" etc.

A few days ago I had trouble charging an electric rental car. When plugging it in, it kept saying "charging scheduled" on the dash, but I couldn't find out how to disable that and make it charge right away. The manual seemed to indicate it could only be done with an app (ugh, disgusting). Went back to the rental company, they made it charge and showed me a video of the screen where to do that. I asked "but how on earth do you get to that screen?". Turned out you could fucking swipe the tablet display to get to a different screen! There was absolutely no indication that this was possible, and the screen even implied that it was modal because there were icons at the bottom which changed the display of the screen.

So you had: zero affordances, modal design on a specific tab, and the different modes showed different tabs at the top, further leading me to believe that this was all there was.

[LtWorf]

I've had long discussions at work with our designer, who thinks that people on desktop computers should perform swipe actions with the mouse rather than the UI reacting to mouse scroll events.

99% of the users are not using the mobile version.

[DrewADesign]

Get a new designer. You have hired a graphic designer that thinks they’re an interface designer. They’re wrong.