|
|
|
|
|
by jagrsw
238 days ago
|
|
Skilled essay, but not an argument. Opens with "As Jung notes" as an appeal to authority, then more name-drops. Misses clear definitions (what counts as "friendship with self"?) and the mechanism (how X->Y). Anecdotes/quotes != proofs. IOW, prestige != proof. Two quick checks 1) strip the names - does the reasoning still stand? 2) Flip to counterexamples - does the thesis survive? We all know people who are hard on themselves but deeply loving to others. Nice essay but treat it as a opinion to test, not a truth to inherit. The thread reads as if the case were already proven. |
|