Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Keyframe 256 days ago
Feels vibe coded. Regardless, what's the intent / purpose of it?
5 comments

Serious question, how does one determine vibe coded or not?
By vibe coding exposure, of course! Loader is something Claude likes to make that way as one example. Also, take a look at the code and comments (disregarding that readme is obvious aigen)

https://github.com/edmundsparrow/gnokestation/tree/main

Only a human can see the disproportionality between the amount of work and the point of it. I, a human, tried it and thought: why does this exist? It's providing nothing. For example, there's a clock "app": but why and how? No human would consider the clock inside of this to be convenient.
The blue-purple gradient alone is a dead giveaway[0].

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AG_791Y-vs4 (The AI Purple Problem)

You can tell by the colors, the icons, the font...most Claude Code apps from scratch will look roughly like this.
The blue/purple gradient is a Claude favourite.

Also CSS animation with stuff fading in and moving in Y axis.

Train LLMs more… this is AI slop. I hope the OP goes and looks as others like Win95 desktop or The Classic Mac project to get a sense of what the purpose is. This. Has no purpose other than to create a desktop look alike for an os that doesn’t exist and so there’s no rules.

It’s fine if you want to create something like that. It’s not very good UX though.

Everyone vibe codes now though right?
So what? The Readme is also easy to find in About System which explains what the project is about.
Still not clear why not just take any webassembly-friendly UI framework like https://www.egui.rs/ (btw compare how much faster it starts).
Readme doesn't say much though.

Upon glancing through the code - yep, AI slop. Fine I guess. It's hacker news, not programmer news.

https://github.com/edmundsparrow/gnokestation/tree/main

Comment feels vibe coded. What's the purpose, intent?
Machine language generated by compilers is compiler slop.