[dangus]

> And the fact that the companies have to implement the system themselves is just crazy.

Isn’t this how most industry regulations work? It’s not like the government provides designs to car companies to reduce emissions or improve crash safety.

[doikor]

Government does issue passports for identiftying their citizens when traveling. It is the one who made/enforces the law that requires that so it is the one who has to provide the means to do that.

Or are you suggesting that anyone should be able to make their own passport?

Or a bit closer example. If there was no official id cards/passports/etc (there currently is no official way of proving your age online) and the government made a law that mandates that one has to be over X to buy alcohol. Who’s job is it to provide the means to prove that you are over X?

For the car a proper analogy would be the goverment requiring drivers license. Who provides the drivers license? Should every manufacturer provide its own?

[dangus]

I think you’re purposefully ignoring my point and misunderstanding the analogy.

Yes, there are things that the directly issues and provides. But the vast majority of regulations are like this one where it basically says “I don’t care how you do it, but you need to check the age of your customers.”

As another example, the government doesn’t make soap but it does mandate that restaurants have hand washing stations.