Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by SirMaster 254 days ago
But you can filter out PFAS from water...
2 comments

you can filter anything out of water...you're just arguing end users should bare the cost of billion dollar corporations doing whatever they want.

The filtration at the levels we're talking about would add thousands of dollars to every household everywhere, all at once.

Talk about something that just is a bit more than, "but you can filter it".

Not saying it's a good approach to solving the problem, but surely you'd want to do the filtering at the water utility level. It would be a lot more cost effective that way.
It probably can't be effectively filtered at utility scale. There are only a small number of effective filtration methods and they basically coalesce to either distillation or reverse osmosis, neither of which is effective at utility scale. The other side of that is that both methods concentrate contaminates when removing them, and distillation puts some contaminates into the air, which means neither is a panacea even at residential scale.

The largest reverse osmosis plant in the world produces 165MGD of water, which is less than is required for any of the top 10 largest US cities, while primarily being used purely for desalination (SWRO). At the levels of filtration and membrane size required for removal of PFAS, it would nearly be impossible to cost effectively filter 200MGD+ of water for a major city.

Okay so how are you going to filter all the water in every water shed, pond, lake, estuary, etc?