Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ZenoArrow 250 days ago
If Python is the only language you have to compare other languages to, all other programming languages are going to look like "Python with X and Y differences". It makes no sense to compare Python to F# when OCaml exists and is a far closer relative. F# isn't quite "OCaml on .NET" but it's pretty close.
1 comments
grumpyprole 250 days ago
It absolutely does make sense to compare it to the worlds most popular programming language, especially when dismissed as "functional programming". Who benefits from an OCaml comparison? You think F# should be marketed to OCaml users who might want to try dotnet? That's a pretty small market.
link
ZenoArrow 249 days ago
Python is the world's most used scripting language, but for application programming languages there are other languages that are widely used and better to compare to F#. For example, C# and Java.
link
grumpyprole 249 days ago
F# was pitched by Microsoft to be used in areas where Python dominates, especially for scripting in the finance domain and "rapid application development". So it doesn't make sense at all that C# and Java are a "better comparison".
link
ZenoArrow 248 days ago
> F# was pitched by Microsoft to be used in areas where Python dominates

Haha, no. Microsoft barely talks about F# at all, and has largely left the evolution of the language up to the open source community that supports it. Furthermore, you shouldn't take your cues about what a language is best suited for from marketing types, you should evaluate it based on its strengths as a language and broader ecosystem. If you seriously doubt that C# is a better comparison to F# than Python, then I suspect you haven't used either C# or F# and you're basing your views on marketing fluff.

link
grumpyprole 248 days ago
Less of the personal attacks please, you know nothing about me. I actually think it is you that is missing context here. Don Syme personally visited and presented at a variety of investment banks. He was the creator not a marketing type. I was present at one of his pitches and met him. One bank, Credit Suisse ended up adopting it. Any comparisons he made to C# where based around readability and time to market (C# is very verbose and boilerplate heavy compared to both Python and F#). This was all on the 2010-2015 timeframe. Python ended up winning in these markets. My point has always been that this now puts it in a difficult position, it's simply not radical enough to disrupt but still carries the perceived "functional programming" barrier to entry.
link