[latchup]

> One of the reasons companies get dysfunctional is low- & mid-tier managers seem to be allergic to the idea of laying out what the priorities are and provide feedback on whether people are working on them or not.

Have you considered the possibility this is not a result of incompetence, but intentional? If these things are never clearly communicated and, more importantly, put in writing, management can just reframe what was agreed upon as best suits them later to deflect any blame if things go sideways. This is a perfectly rational move, since they hold all the power to do so.

I think a lot of what is wrong with this discussion is that people implicitly assume management is honest and communicates openly and sincerely. This is sadly only true in a small fraction of cases, likely because the incentives point squarely in the opposite direction: those who judge the game are always better off cheating.

[apwell23]

exactly. my last job the project i was working on suddenly became "my project" where manager wanted to "give me a win" by shipping. it became my project when we discovered all the way in the end that what he had come up with isn't viable at all. thing i was telling from the get go but he didn't listen and adamant that it would be fine.

we even had it in writing the i had objected to his scheme and that he overrode it but that document was completely hidden from upper managment.