Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by 1gn15 261 days ago
Yes.

(The "takers" also do not have copyright protection.)

2 comments

So basically the only winners should be:

- owners of large platforms who don't care what "content"[0] is successful or if creators get rewarded, as long as there is content to show between ads

- large corporations who can afford to protect their content with DRM

Is that correct?

Do you expect it to play out differently? Game it out in your head.

[0]: https://eev.ee/blog/2025/07/03/the-rise-of-whatever/#:~:text...

The vast majority of DRM is cracked very quickly; the only reason DRM cracking tools aren't more widespread is because of copyright law and the idiotic anti-circumvention provisions.

Consider that even DRM'd content is on torrent sites within hours of release.

Great, you've just removed any incentive for people to make anything.
The vast amounts of permissively licensed works directly contradicts you.

Even if you take away copyright, there are plenty of incentives to create. Copyright is not the sole reason people create.

Vague. Are you talking about reasons to create like the joy of creating? Your bio describes you as a 'tech entrepreneur', not 'DIY tinkerer'. So I'll assume that when you spend a great deal of time entrepreneuring something, you do so with the hope of remuneration. Maybe not by licensing the copyright, but in some form.

Permissive licenses are great in software, where SAAS is an alternative route to getting paid. How does that work if you're a musician, artist, writer, or filmmaker who makes a living selling the rights to your creative output? It doesn't.

> Vague. Are you talking about reasons to create like the joy of creating?

That’s one of them, but I really don’t have to be specific about the reasons. I just have to point out the existence of permissively licensed works. You said:

> Great, you've just removed any incentive for people to make anything.

This is very obviously untrue. Perhaps you meant to say “…you’ve just removed some incentives for people to make some things”?

It's ok I don't have any talent so that won't affect me