[Balinares]

It's a boon if the goal is to write code then go home. It's a loaded footgun if the goal is to compose a stack and run it in production within SLO.

Python type hints manage to largely preserve the flexibility while seriously increasing confidence in the correctness, and lack of crashing corner cases, of each component. There's really no good case against them at this point outside of one-off scripts. (And even there, I'd consider it good practice.)

As a side bonus, lack of familiarity with Python type hints is a clear no-hire signal, which saves a lot of time.

[jshen]

People say this all the time, but I've never seen any data proving it's true. Should be rather easy too, I'm at a big company and different teams use different languages. The strictly typed languages do to have fewer defects, and those teams don't ship features any faster than the teams using loosely typed languages.

What I've experienced is that other factors make the biggest difference. Teams that write good tests, have good testing environments, good code review processes, good automation, etc tend to have fewer defects and higher velocity. Choice of programming language makes little to no difference.

[zelphirkalt]

I think with types there is a risk of typing things too early or too strictly or types nudging one to go in a direction, that reduces the applicability and flexibility of the final outcome. Some things can be difficult to express in types and then people choose easier to type solutions, that are not as flexible and introduce more work later, when things need to change, due to that inflexibility or limited applicability.

[coldtea]

>It's a boon if the goal is to write code then go home. It's a loaded footgun if the goal is to compose a stack and run it in production within SLO.

Never has been an issue in practice...

[untrust]

Did you forget /s at the end of this?

I work at big tech and the number of bad deploys and reverts I've seen go out due to getting types wrong is in the hundreds. Increased type safety would catch 99% of the reverts I've seen.

[almosthere]

Also have fun depending on libraries 10 years old as no one likes upgrades over fear of renames.

[stackskipton]

Ops type here, I’ve got multiple stories where devs have screwed up with typing and it’s caused downstream problems.