[boomboomsubban]

>it was loaning them 1:N instead of 1:1 because "pandemic

It was over loaning them 1:1, the pandemic actions were barely mentioned as part of the lawsuit and the result is that 1:1 loaning was ruled illegal. The only harm the pandemic actions did was to public opinion.

[ocdtrekkie]

Or, the 1:1 lending was probably okay until Kahle showed his willingness to abandon copyright entirely with the emergency library, and publishers decided it was worth putting down CDL as a whole.

[boomboomsubban]

The book publishers had been building a case against the CDL for a decade. They saw an opportunity to control the narrative and took it.

[CYR1X]

That's what I said? The pandemic excuse was IA's reason for doing it at first.