Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by asdhtjkujh 279 days ago
I should know better, but I'm still surprised they're shipping this version of Liquid Glass. Performance is stable but there are so many UI bugs and inconsistencies that haven't been fixed from early betas, including low-hanging fruit that a second year design student would notice. I don't mind change or interface elements moving around but keynote-level UI overhauls should be fully implemented at launch, otherwise people are stuck using a broken OS for a year.

At this point I'm doubtful that these will be addressed in the 26.X updates, so the wait begins for 27.0...
3 comments
pndy 278 days ago
Heh. I can imagine Cook having his own O'Reilly's "We'll do it live!" moment for Liquid Glass initial backlash.

Fixing this mess will surely take a while but then they use that as PR in future keynotes, saying how hard they were working on it.

link
thewebguyd 279 days ago
Yeah I shouldn't be surprised this was allowed to launch today, but yet I am.

I ran the whole beta on all my devices. Every new beta I'd ask myself "Surely they fixed 'x' by now, right?" and we advanced, beta after beta, with the same bugs and performance regressions all the way up to launch.

The icons still need to redraw in the settings app and app library. It's overall sluggish. The drop shadows are huge in the finder and other apps top bar. If you turn on always show scrollbars they get cut off at a weird angle due to the excessive corner radius.

My iPhone 16 PM runs hot all the time, even on release now, vs. iOS 18.

I don't mind the transparency or glass effects. I actually like it in some areas. But man does it need some serious polish and bug fixing, and a lot of time and effort spent on consistency.

This should never have went live in this state. I consider .0 just another beta, really. Actual release will probably be .2 or .3

link
jihadjihad 279 days ago
> I consider .0 just another beta, really. Actual release will probably be .2 or .3

This is good advice for Apple software in general. Always let it burn in for a couple patch releases. Being a guinea pig for Apple is a losing bet.

link
al_borland 278 days ago
This is always how it goes. The big change happens, and it’s refined over time.

For what it’s worth, there where threads here on HN where people complained at length about the bugs and inconsistencies in the previous version of the Apple operating systems.

link
AlexandrB 278 days ago
Yes, and many of those bugs and inconsistencies never went away. We're now at the point of Apple piling new bugs on top of old bugs.
link