[josephg]

I’d be fascinated to see a comparison with SPDK. That bypasses the kernel’s NVMe / SSD driver and controls the whole device from user space - which is supposed to avoid a lot of copies and overhead.

You might be able to set up SPDK to send data directly into the cpu cache? It’s one of those things I’ve wanted to play with for years but honestly I don’t know enough about it.

https://spdk.io/

[jared_hulbert]

spdk and I go way back. I'm confident it'd be about the same, possibly ~200-300MB/s more, I was pretty close to the rated throughput of the drives. Io_uring has really closed the gap that used to exist between the in kernel and userspace solutions.

With the Intel connection they might have explicit support for DDIO. Good idea.

[benlwalker]

SPDK will be able to fully saturate the PCIe bandwidth from a single CPU core here (no secret 6 threads inside the kernel). The drives are your bottleneck so it won't go faster, but it can use a lot less CPU.

But with SPDK you'll be talking to the disk, not to files. If you changed io_uring to read from the disk directly with O_DIRECT, you wouldn't have those extra 6 threads either. SPDK would still be considerably more CPU efficient but not 6x.

DDIO is a pure hardware feature. Software doesn't need to do anything to support it.

Source: SPDK co-creator