Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by csomar 289 days ago
The battery (am assuming it's just sand and metal) should be very cheap compared to Lithium especially in the places where you generated solar energy (they are hot and have a lot of sand).

The problem is: is it profitable to even store energy there? There is no mention beyond "In operation, the sand battery has demonstrated a round trip efficiency of 90 percent.". That doesn't mean much if you do not compare it to Lithium and you don't give me a breakdown of the costs.

The other thing: Size. Is that big thing enough to store energy for a city? a neighborhood? A building? A house?

If it's enough just for a house, then I have trouble seeing this scale.

3 comments

1 MW is enough to heat somewhere between 100 and 2000 houses, depending on other factors like insulation, climate, and house size.
It's right in the title. 1 MW/100 MWh.
If your house is consuming 100MWh in heating on any reasonable timescale, you, ah, have problems :)
But at least the problems will be short lived! Should reach self-ignition pretty quickly with that, even in the middle of Finnish winter.