Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pdw 293 days ago
Security researchers rarely fix bugs. They don't see it as their job, and it requires a very different skill set than finding or exploiting them anyway.
2 comments

This is misplaced in this case.

The author mentioned CVE-2021-26708, which is very similar to this bug, and in fact the author both exploited it and authored the upstream fix in the kernel.

> and it requires a very different skill set than finding or exploiting them anyway

I disagree with that. Exploiting bugs is really hard, and if you can exploit them, you absolutely know enough about the kernel in order to patch it.

Sure, architecting a kernel, making code maintainable, that's a software engineering skill. But fixing a use-after-free? That's easier than exploiting it, of course they can fix it.

There’s the technical challenge, and then there’s the process challenge.
Sending an email with a simple patch is not a challenge.
Thanks for submitting the fix here!
You might want to read the thread you are responding to instead of posting knee-jerk reactions.
"fixing bugs" gets lets street creds than "hacking into things"