you're quoting a lot of legal code for someone starting all of their posts with "IANAL"
The point of commenting IANAL, is that legal code is complicated. The ACLU is likely giving "best-practices", but that's not legal code. It's guidelines.
This feels pretty first-amendment to me, but I have little doubt that SCOTUS would think that people's first-amendment rights are less important than the Gov't's ability to do what it's doing.
I just also think that SCOTUS is wrong and full of very political actors who are grossly partial towards the current administration.
The point of commenting IANAL, is that legal code is complicated. The ACLU is likely giving "best-practices", but that's not legal code. It's guidelines.
This feels pretty first-amendment to me, but I have little doubt that SCOTUS would think that people's first-amendment rights are less important than the Gov't's ability to do what it's doing.
I just also think that SCOTUS is wrong and full of very political actors who are grossly partial towards the current administration.