Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lugao 289 days ago
It's funny because you can't measure borders due to the coastline paradox.
3 comments

I'm not aware of any 2 countries having their border be a natural coastline
Same principle applies to rivers, though, and there are lots of river borders.
It isn't the same principle. Firstly, coastlines are more jagged because they are hit by waves perpendicularly, while rivers are shaped by water flowing along the banks, smoothing them. Secondly, the borders are typically defined by either the thalweg (greatest depth) or median line, either being smoother lines than the banks. Thirdly, river borders are then in practice defined by measuring the coordinates of particular sample points along the idealized line and then using straight lines or simple mathematical curves to connect these, forming a simple non-fractal boundary.
You could say the exact same set of objections to shoreline paradox.
But most borders are not defined as "on the shoreline", they are defined using something reliable.
Exactly. The coastline paradox is a mathematical curiousity, not a practical objection to measuring things. Coastlines are not infinite length in practice. You define a system of measurement then a length in that system
What? Neither of those three applies to a shoreline.
Physical shorelines instantiations of a true fractal are always limited. I'd go so far as to say that there is no such real object in the world.
Doesn't matter in this context.
Eh. If you care about relative measurements it doesn't matter much. Pick a sensible resolution, stick with it, you got yourself a ranking.
It also makes sense to pick a resolution because coastline changes on an hourly basis (and minute-basis, for rivers during rainfall), so that these differences would not massively affect the measurement every single second