A person who has schizophrenia and hallucinates to a greater extent than LLMs are clearly defective and not intelligent or sentient.
Because of this we should euthanize all schizophrenics. Just stab them to death or put a bullet in their heads right? I mean they aren’t intelligent or sentient so you shouldn’t feel anything when you do this.
I’m baffled as to why people think of this in terms of PRs. Like the LLM is intelligent but everyone’s like oh it’s not following my command perfectly therefore it’s not intelligent.
They would have issues even remaining employed. AI defenders are very quick to point out "humans mistakes too", but that is a false equivalence because humans learn. If a junior makes a really stupid mistake, when I show him the correct way he won't make that mistake again. An AI will, because (as people correctly point out) it has no actual intelligence.
There’s examples of humans who can’t learn. Have you seen the movie memento.
There are cases where humans lose all ability to form long term memories and outside of a timed context window they remember nothing. That context window is minutes at best.
According to your logic these people have no actual intelligence or sentience. Therefore they should be euthanized. You personally can grab a gun and execute each of these people one by one with a bullet straight to the head because clearly these people have no actual intelligence or sentience. That’s the implication of your logic.
It’s called anterograde amnesia. Do you see how your logic can justify gassing all these people holocaust style?
When I point out the flaw in your logic do you use the new facts to form a new conclusion? Or do you rearrange the facts to maintain support for your existing conclusion?
If you did the later I hate to tell you this, it wasn’t very intelligent. It was biased. But given that you’re human, that’s what you most likely did and it’s normal. But pause for a second and try to do the former of using the new facts to form a different more nuanced conclusion.
Because of this we should euthanize all schizophrenics. Just stab them to death or put a bullet in their heads right? I mean they aren’t intelligent or sentient so you shouldn’t feel anything when you do this.
I’m baffled as to why people think of this in terms of PRs. Like the LLM is intelligent but everyone’s like oh it’s not following my command perfectly therefore it’s not intelligent.