Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by toomuchtodo 297 days ago
Sound comment, but a couple of points. There is no such thing as an absolute free market capitalistic system in existence today. Each system has thumbs on the scale in different ways to encourage different outcomes ("picking winners and losers") in some capacity. And while the Fed pulls the levers, trust is the foundation. Trust in consistency, the rule of law, and property rights. This is why US treasuries were considered the safest financial asset in the world. Once you begin to lose trust, the entire foundation shakes.

Also, I'd argue the bond market is far more powerful than the Fed. The Fed can set short term target rates, but the bond market sets longer term rates. The bond market is what kept this admin in check earlier in the year. One might say they are the Fifth Estate, after journalism and the three branches of US government. "Whoever holds the gold makes the rules."

https://tisegroup.com/news/2025/the-power-of-the-bond-market...

https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/08/12/what-to-k...

https://www.bloomberg.com/explainers/bond-vigilantes | https://archive.today/XcRIq

> Have bond vigilantes influenced government decision-making before?

> Yes. In fact, they’ve already influenced Trump’s decision-making. In the hours after Trump’s long-awaited tariffs on most imports to the US went into effect on April 9, the bond market tanked. Many investors, concerned that the duties would accelerate inflation and reduce foreign demand for US assets, started dumping their holdings in order to pressure the administration to reverse course.

> It worked: Just 13 hours after the tariffs had gone into effect, Trump announced that he would pause them, and yields came down. “The bond market is very tricky,” he conceded. “I was watching it.”

1 comments

That’s a solid point about the bond market. I’ll have to work it into my paradigm.

We’re on the general same page (i.e., conventional wisdom is wrong) but I have a counter-point.

Yes, trust is important. Those who have been favored and enriched by the Fed trusts that it will continue to do so (for them). Sum that up over time and we have what we have:

- wider and wider financial inequality

- more money and assets in fewer hands

- excessive federal gov debt

- more frequent bubbles of some sort

- etc.

I’m not so sure the bond market is at fault.