Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by immibis 298 days ago
And you identify the paradox of tolerance, almost.

Killing people is bad, but Adolf Hitler is bad. So is it okay to kill Adolf Hitler, or would that make you as bad as him?

What if you were sent back in time, to before he did the bad things?

This is the extreme version of the "antifascist is fascist" debate. In the current time most of the bad people are not Adolf Hitler and we don't kill them and we aren't even 100% certain they'll be bad because we don't have time machines (only pattern recognition), but the same moral quandaries apply mutatis mutandis.

Some questions don't have simple answers. And it's better to at least acknowledge that, than to assert a particular simple answer, as a defense mechanism to allow yourself to continue believing there is always one.

1 comments

The “paradox of intolerance” is bullshit that makes a nice cartoon. It embraces a false dichotomy
This comment is a thought-terminating emotional outburst with no logical substance.