Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tomasGiden 305 days ago
How about in-app purchases and subscriptions? The code is already there. Is it abusive?

Is it abusive because it is tied to hardware?

No, I see it as the opposite. I see it as Volkswagen simplifying production by limiting variability and giving you the option to get a less capable product at at a cheaper price.

A 6 and a 8 core processor is probably the same die also and produced at the same cost. Maybe 2 cord were turned off because they were faulty or maybe they were turned off because some people don’t have the need and money for 8 cores. Does it matter? Now they can still buy a computer. Is that a bad thing?

3 comments

> How about in-app purchases and subscriptions? The code is already there. Is it abusive?

Sometimes yes and sometimes no. Pure software is a bit different than hardware as copies are effectively zero cost. Same would go for e-books, music, etc. Not that they get a full free pass, these media can also engage in abusive practices.

> Is it abusive because it is tied to hardware?

Yes. Another example of the absurdity is if you want to buy half an apple and the store charges you enough to cover the costs of a full apple, then pull out a full apple and destroy half of it before handing it to you. Does that seem ok? Putting in extra effort to make something worse is bad.

> A 6 and a 8 core processor is probably the same die also and produced at the same cost. Maybe 2 cord were turned off because they were faulty or maybe they were turned off because some people don’t have the need and money for 8 cores.

Big difference between these two cases. If the two extra cores were faulty, then charging a lower price makes sense. Like paying less for used tires that have some wear on them. But taking a perfectly good chip and purposefully disabling two cores is like taking a belt sander to a new tire and then charging less.

It's not the same comparison at all. Part of the problem why IT people developing electric shitboxes has ruined the car industry.
I personally think the answer to this is "yes” and have never bought any product that did this. I don't even do subscriptions.

The turbo example is insane. It's literally unwanted dead weight probably slightly negatively affecting fuel economy.