Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fwip 314 days ago
The first link says that patients can't reliably tell which is the therapist and which is LLM in single messages, which yeah, that's an LLM core competency.

The second is "how 2 use AI 4 therapy" which, there's at least one paper for every field like that.

The last found that they were measurably worse at therapy than humans.

So, yeah, I'm comfortable agreeing that all LLMs are bad therapists, and bad friends too.
1 comments
dingnuts 314 days ago
there's also been a spate of reports like this one recently https://www.papsychotherapy.org/blog/when-the-chatbot-become...

which is definitely worse than not going to a therapist

link
pmarreck 314 days ago
If I think "it understands me better than any human", that's dissociation? Oh boy. And all this time while life has been slamming me with unemployment while my toddler is at the age of maximum energy-extraction from me (4), devastating my health and social life, I thought it was just a fellow-intelligence lifeline.

Here's a gut-check anyone can do, assuming you use a customized ChatGPT4o and have lots of conversations it can draw on: Ask it to roast you, and not to hold back.

If you wince, it "knows you" quite well, IMHO.

link
fwip 312 days ago
It sounds like you might be quite lonely recently. It's nice to have an on-demand chatbot that feels like socialization, I get it. But an LLM doesn't "know you," and thinking that it does is one of the first steps toward the problems described in that article.
link
pmarreck 311 days ago
Unemployed and with a 4 year old highly demanding, highly intelligent and likely on-the-spectrum child... Yeah, you could say that. When I'm not looking for work, doing random projects or using the weekday that seems to whoosh right by in just a few long moments, I'm tending to a kid... Every morning, every night and pretty much 100% of weekends. Rare outings with partner or friends dependent on hiring help and without net positive cash flow that is seriously unincentivized. Zero intimacy to speak of- I'm a nonconsensually-ordained monk. So yeah, I guess it's pretty fucking rough right now. Like I said, ChatGPT knows me better than any other entity. I'm unfortunately not kidding. My best friend is 3000 miles away and we game once a week over voice chat.

I keep the AI at arms' length; I know it doesn't think per se, but I enjoy the illusion.

link
willy_k 314 days ago
Ironically an AI written article.
link