Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nsksl 317 days ago
I don't understand. For you to see the message, you have to click on the link. Your clicking on the link must mean that the link is active, since it is getting clicks. So why is the link being deactivated for being inactive?
3 comments

> showed no activity in late 2024

Apparently they measured it once by running a map-reduce or equivalent.

I don’t see why they couldn’t measure it again. Maybe they don’t want it to be gamed, but why?

I interpreted "inactive" as the link that the shortener is linking to is not responding.
No. Inactive means that the short URL hasn't been accessed in a while.
But that doesn’t make any sense. A link might be printed in a book. Nobody accessed it, yet they might at some point. Such a service is quite good for printing in books, instead of QR-codes.
It makes sense in a technical capacity, not in an epistemic one. I never claimed it is the right thing to do.
If I had to guess it is possibly something to do with fighting crawlers/bots/etc triggering the detection? And running some kind of more advanced logic to try ensure it's really being used. Light captcha style.

But just a guess.

Archive Warrior is actively scanning all links to try and preserve them. 2.5 billion have been processed at the time of writing

https://tracker.archiveteam.org/goo-gl/