[uamgeoalsk]

It's worth being careful with broad characterizations like this. Attributing complex policy opposition to fringe beliefs or bad faith motives oversimplifies the issue and shuts down good faith discussion. Whatever one’s views, that kind of framing isn’t helpful.

[dpkirchner]

But in this case it's absolutely true -- I've yet to see any other reason for Republicans to be opposed to national IDs. Have you?