[mintone]

The lede is buried at the end of this article.

> Later iOS 26 beta releases show Apple reducing transparency and adding blur effects for better readability.

This is a beta release. It is a work in progress. When iOS 7’s betas came out the reaction was similarly negative. I would suggest we wait and see what the system evolves into; by the time we get to iOS 27 I am quite sure that Apple will have found the right balance.

[Someone1234]

I've observed that some people like to gatekeep others from being allowed to criticize the beta, but then when the final version releases they gatekeep criticizing that too because "you should have given feedback during the beta!"

It is just a way people try to shutdown being critical of Apple's stuff in general. It is tiresome.

[mpalmer]

When Apple is dropping press releases trumpeting their "meticulously crafted" design that "makes even the simplest of interactions more fun and magical", it is not persuasive to cry "beta!"

Even the screenshots in the press release - Apple's best foot forward - were criticized more or less immediately; it's not like the problems with the design are rare edge cases.

Apple clearly owns the decision to go this route. No one forced them to announce it before refining it internally. It remains to be seen how drastically they will have to walk it back. Whether or not they rework it enough to reduce complaints, I can't see how they can call it a win in the end. They will anyway.

[vsl]

Beta 3 walked it back and added frosting.

Beta 4 went back again.

As for being "sure" Apple will find the right balance, they never fixed usability regressions in macOS introduced in the last redesign. And they have ~10 weeks to fix all this.

[crinkly]

It’s going to be another apple intelligence aka “how the fuck do I make it go away?”

[CRConrad]

Ah. So they're reducing transparency to get better readability... If reducing transparency increases readability, then wouldn't the best readability occur at zero transparency?

Readability is obviously good for something. Is transparency?

I am quite sure that "the right balance" is zero transparency, but only about 99% sure Apple won't "find" that.

[pjmlp]

iOS 7 remains to this day a common meme among Apple developer community regarding design going too far, so naturally finding the right balance is kind of questionable.

[Nevermark]

Yes beta is a work in progress.

But so is alpha, which is where looniness gets to live without judgement. Beta is supposed to be polished and working well, except where there are explicit warnings of incomplete or sketchy functionality. I.e. small areas that are still alpha.

Which is the opposite of how Apple framed "liquid glass" in the beta.

Apple lowered the bar on its beta. Strong feedback is how customers suggest a course correction at a higher level.

[deadbabe]

Cool, so I will wait for iOS 27.