Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by 0x5FC3 333 days ago
I agree, but the CIA is quite out of line, quite a lot of times. Specifically in its current iteration, I do not see the agency being high up in the absolute requirement for the capacity to govern.
2 comments

> but the CIA is quite out of line, quite a lot of times

More than other intelligence agencies? Extant or historical?

Intelligence is messy. Here. And among our enemies. We have to contain that messiness domestically, to keep it from consuming us. In that way, it's analogous to our immune system. And just like our immune system, turning it off means all the other out-of-line elements around the world now have easy pickings over you.

The CIA has been more destructive than other modern agencies because it's far reaching. It's not more evil than other ICs. Just more capable. I'm not thrilled to learn who occupies that vacuum if the CIA goes away; almost by definition, it won't be anyone benevolent.

What things has the CIA done in the last quarter century that you object to as being out of line?
Torture, black prison sites, lied to Congress?

How is that even a question?

We will probably have to wait another quarter century for them to be public.
Okay, so then when you were talking about your problems with the CIA "Specifically in its current iteration", you were talking about what exactly?
The behemoth it has become after years of toppling govts, slinging drugs, the MKs, etc., without any real repercussions.