Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by kevinsync 331 days ago
IMO file/folder structure in a project is a geographic mapping exercise. It's not that far off from city planning. I think it's so important to design the structure and naming conventions of a project with the ultimate goal of aesthetically-pleasing, human-understandable spatial organization of digital artifacts. You "go here" to "see that". This "lives here". You travel to the destination of the thing you're looking for, and gain a deeper understanding of how the world is constructed that you are inhabiting.

This is one of my pet peeves with any kind of cloud file storage -- oftentimes they try to reinvent or abstract away the idea of a deeply-nested filesystem tree, and it just feels anti-human to me lol

Edit: I hit submit and then acknowledged I was kind of ranting about something else entirely from the paper itself!
3 comments
suzzer99 331 days ago
Agreed. I always try to design apps so that renaming or changing the file structure causes minimal disruption. I want as little friction to refactoring as possible.

I'm a huge fan of files that just work wherever you put them (think pages on a website), and then relative import paths to all their subcomponents. For subcomponents shared throughout the app, I always use absolute paths so that reafactoring my page-level components into subfolders won't break the import.

link
astrange 331 days ago
This is my problem with almost every UI framework invented in the overengineered era of the 90s-2000s.

Try to find a feature in basically any open-source C++ or Java GUI app just by looking for the code that does it. You can't, because there isn't any code that does anything! Instead there's several different widely scattered pieces of boilerplate, none of which individually has any meat in it.

link
stillpointlab 331 days ago
I totally agree, and I use LLMs for this. I have a script that will output my directory structure (just the folders and filenames + the lines of code; aggregate for folders and per file). Then I ask the LLM to give me feedback. Surprisingly this has lead to some very useful feedback and improvements.
link