Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jt_b 344 days ago
Fortunately there are a lot of great alternatives to the ESRI lock-in, and FOSS has a long and rich tradition in Geo.
1 comments
fsloth 344 days ago
What are the ESRI alternatives?
link
scanny 344 days ago
QGIS for ArcMap/ArcGIS Geoserver for their REST based servers (ArcGIS Enterprise). GRASS and GDAL do the leg work of much processing found in the spatial toolboxes and such.

However those tools do not have the polish that ESRI kit does, but at leas you’re not paying the licensing!

- former ESRI consultant

link
morganherlocker 344 days ago
> However those tools do not have the polish that ESRI kit does, but at leas you’re not paying the licensing!

Arguably they have more polish, but less GUI. The open GIS world is more CLI, database, and library driven, which can be an advantage for many users trying to build high reliability or scaling systems.

link
misswaterfairy 344 days ago
Except most GIS Analysts aren't, or don't understand how to.

That's a lot of the reason why Esri still wins a lot of contracts.

link
fsloth 331 days ago
Potentially this is something Clude Code, Cursor and other interactive LLM tools will disrupt. I watched at work a former GIS consultant without software engineering background delve into novel Python stack with Claude and hot damn … they are delivering value.
link