[stoneyhrm1]

> "good catch, I'll fix that"

I see this a lot and even done so myself, I think a lot of people in the industry are a bit too socially-aware and think if they start a discussion they look like they're trying too hard.

It's stupid yes, but plenty of times I've started discussions only to be brushed off or not even replied to, and I believed it was because my responses were too long and nobody actually cared.

[Cthulhu_]

I feel the same way; we use Gitlab in our day to day, and often I find myself writing a long reply after fixing a code review issue, describing what I changed, resources used, etc... then hitting the "resolve" button, which collapses the comment and unless the reviewer has enabled notifications and actually reads them, I doubt they would ever see my well thought-out response.

But then, for me, writing is a way to organize thought as well, plus these remarks will stay in the thread for future reference. In theory anyway, in practice it's likely they'll switch from Gitlab to something else and all comments will be lost forever.

Which makes me wish for systems that archive review remarks into Git somehow. I'm sure they exist, but they're not commonly used.

[jameshart]

That doesn’t sound like ‘social awareness’, it sounds like paranoia