Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by abtinf 356 days ago
> misinformation

Nothing screams “not living in Soviet Russia” like having a ministry of truth.

2 comments

So is being fed propaganda 24/7, the KGB seems to be winning by reading some of these comments.

I don't see kids being banned from reading history books, which would be more like the world you're describing, I see a country which is pretty multicultural and open minded trying it's best to protect itself from the absolute nonsense that circulates online. When I was a kid, I could only watch certain TV shows because my bed time was 7:30-8pm, that's when the "naughty stuff" came on TV. Was that the ministry of truth at work?

Do you have any idea what kids are exposed to now ? I mean the answer is probably, no, you have no idea. But judging by the rot I see my younger friends and family members watch and regurgitate, I can tell you, it's not great.

yep mutual deligitimation and hasbara are operating in full force. over 80 countries have "cyber troops" - there are so many countries trying to destroy the social fabric of the west. why shouldn't we shield our children who have no way of understanding or protecting themselves from it. plus the fact that the "thought and ideological leaders" of this generation have no thoughts or coherent ideologies is pretty telling.
> “not living in Soviet Russia”

Nothing screams "fear mongering" like comparing with living in Soviet Russia.

Look, we can argue all day. There is no right or wrong answer. I don't fully support the govts initiative but I also don't want Meta/X/Google to have unlimited powers like they do in the US.

> I don't fully support the govts initiative but I also don't want Meta/X/Google to have unlimited powers like they do in the US.

Various large US tech companies played a central role in drafting this initiative. I don't think you're reasoning about this clearly.

How exactly does this curtail their powers?

Can you explain how limiting a regular citizen's freedom constrains Meta/X/Google's power?