[DocTomoe]

The cynic in me says we'll be seeing articles about blog owners getting fractions of a tenth of a penny while Cloudflare pockets most of the revenue.

And of course it will eventually be rolled out for everyone, meaning there will be a Cloudflare-Net (where you only can read if you give Cloudflare your credit card number), and then successively more competing infrastructure services (Akamai, AWS, ... meaning we get into a fractured marketplace kind of situation, similar to how you need dozens of streaming abos to watch "everything").

For AI, it will make crawling more expensive for the large guys and lead to higher costs for AI users - which means all of us - while at the same time making it harder for smaller companies to start something new, innovative. And it will make information less available on AI models.

Finally, there’s a parallel here to the net neutrality debate: once access becomes conditional on payment or corporate gatekeeping, the original openness of the web erodes.

This is not the good news for netizens it sounds like.

[vasilzhigilei]

I worked at Cloudflare for 3 years until very recently, and it's simply not the culture to behave in the way that you are describing.

There exists a strong sense of doing the thing that is healthiest for the Internet over what is the most profit-extractive, even when the cost may be high to do so or incentives great to choose otherwise. This is true for work I've been involved with as well as seeing the decisions made by other teams.

[focusedone]

That's the impression I get from Cloudflare - it seems like a group of highly skilled people attempting to solve real problems for the benefit of the web as a whole. As both a paid business user and a free user for home projects, I deeply appreciate what they've accomplished and how generously they allow unpaid users to benefit from their work.

I worry about what happens someday when leadership changes and the priority becomes value extraction rather than creation, if that makes sense. We've seen it so many times with so many other tech companies, it's difficult to believe it won't happen to Cloudflare at some point.

[vollbrecht]

You are probably right that this is not the case right now. 25 years ago you could say the same about google employees. Incentives change with time, and once infrastructure is in place it's nearly impossible to get rid of it again.

So one better makes sure that it has not the potential to further introduce gatekeepers, where later such gatekeepers will realize that, in order to continue to live, they need to make a profit over everything else, and then everything is out of the window.

[seanw444]

Unfortunately, even if it is as you describe, human nature is such that it will not stay that way forever. Likely not even for long.

[fragmede]

And then 20 years later Cloudflare hits hard times and gets bought by someone you don't like. The problem is that much power concentrated in any one place.

[Workaccount2]

It's worse than that, it strongly incentivizes creating agents that spin up blogs, fill them with LLM vomit, and then enable "pay-for-training".

It's basically creating a "get paid to spam the internet with anything" system.

[vevoe]

tbf I think that's already been happening for a while now