Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by qsort 362 days ago
You do understand that asking to work 32 hours rather than 40 is exactly the same thing as asking a 25% raise right?

I'm not against workers asking for more money in the slightest, they don't do that nearly as often as they should, but this sounds a bit like "big brain idea: give me more money lol".

6 comments

No it's not the same thing. The difference is productivity growth. If you ask 25% more ceteris paribus, someone has to give something up. In this case, nobody has to give something up.
>No it's not the same thing.

... screams the economics-illiterate left. If they pay you money for your work/time, then it's by definition fungible.

No sense in responding, people. This person can't be saved. Move on.
It is different, because productive output does not go down by 20% when working hours go down by 20%.

e.g. See "Four-day week trial: study finds lower stress but no cut in output" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19198649

The OP is arguing this is even more true when AI does routine tasks, and the remaining tasks are more creative, strategic, inspiration-based.

I'll be sure to remind myself of that next time I wish I had more time to spend watching my daughter grow up. Sure, I may miss some seminal moments but the raise I get at the end of the year is just as good.
If asking someone to work during an evening or during the weekend in order to make a deadline is not lowering their salary, then someone working less hours per week is not raising their salary.
Despite what they say, time does not equal money.
Or it’s "asking" for more of the productivity to go to workers instead of the capitalists.