Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mattbrewsbytes 358 days ago
I've been using LoseIt and I've had a successful six months this year and realized a key thing: linking to Apple Fitness was slowing my progress. Here's why - the app tracks "workout calories" at a very high rate and it was essentially calculating my daily calorie budget back to maintenance calories, i.e. not losing and not gaining. I unlinked Apple Fitness from the app. Check the math from your app, use a TDEE calculator as a reference, a lot of apps and fitness devices over estimate calories burned.

I just realized I follow a single responsibility principle for apps: LoseIt for calorie tracking, Apple Fitness for tracking exercise and Streaks for tracking habits. They're all a tap or two away, no need to combine them for me.

Regarding custom recipes - I've found the search results in LoseIt have enough results that I can judge what I ate and pick something pretty close. Calories on packages of food or published by restaurants are working with estimated averages anyways so my opinion is being exact isn't going to result in more weight loss, for me it will result in frustration and likely I stop tracking. If I'm +/- 100-200 calories for the day, I'm still within the range of losing and this fits more with making changes I can stick with. Not saying others should adopt this approach, just sharing my thinking on it, you do you.