Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by z_rex 361 days ago
A spinning generator is not outputting 10x it's rated current over any significant amount of time. You can only add so much steam or fuel to a turbine, and the rotor has a lot of inertia, but not enough to account for 10X its rated capacity for a second. The electrical switchyards would trip nearly instantaneously if it's connected plant output 10X its rated input.
3 comments

A properly running grid with spinning generators never needs the 10x rated current. More importantly, oscillations are dampened by the rotating masses.
Let alone the transmission lines totally catching fire after a 10X output increase.
Where are you getting this information from?

Although I’m hardly an expert on power lines(my factory produces HV switchgear), a 1s short circuit current rating of 10x(actually more) is normal, standard to IEC norms.

Arcing.
I think they meant 10x current not 10x voltage, so no arcing.
You can if the load was 10x under max. before getting tripped.

Misaligned oscillation can occurs under ANY load.

Batteries would also be able to 10x if their load was 10x under max, so I'm not sure how this is relevant to GP's point.
The inverter would melt presumably.
Just looking for an excuse. Lol