Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by reactordev 354 days ago
Was totally interested until I read its play-by-post and he keeps track of all the troop movements and results. Not exactly what I had pictured in my head before I clicked the link. I don’t understand how people have the time to play things by mail in realtime. I want an evening escape, not a lifetime achievement.
6 comments

> I don’t understand how people have the time to play things by mail in realtime

It's not via mail, it's via discord; there are more details in the submission:

"I set up a channel on a reasonably-popular RPG discord server I’m on, then each commander gets their own thread, using discord’s thread feature. Each commander then gets a little doc with their character writeup and a sheet with their army numbers. They write messages to me, I reply and notify them as events occur, and I keep track of everything on a big spreadsheet and a running Photoshop map file. (...)"

---

Also note that in early wargames writing down orders was part of the game, e.g.:

"Players do not speak to each other. Instead, they communicate with their teammates and the umpire through written messages. This is so that the enemy team cannot hear their plans. This is also so that the umpire can delay or block messages if he feels the circumstances on the battlefield warrant it. In the early 19th century, officers in the field communicated over long distances through messengers. There was no radio in those days. Messengers needed time to reach the recipient, and could be delayed or intercepted by the enemy. The umpire can simulate this problem by holding on to a player's message for a round or two before giving it to the recipient, never giving it, or even give it to the enemy."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kriegsspiel

Back in the day my buddies and I used to play Civilization 2 by swapping a floppy with the save file back and forth every day we met in school.
Ignoring outright save-file manipulation, this style does tweak the strategy of the game.

You have to assume the fog of war does not exist. The enemy knows exactly what you are constructing, no secretly rushing a wonder. It also means you could have a much better feel for the probabilities of winning a military engagement. You could locally run through several turns, pitting their army against yours to see the most likely outcome. The moment the odds tilt in your favor, you would be incentivized to seize the victory, knowing the enemy is running the same calculus.

> I want an evening escape

That would be giving orders for one turn. Why the rush?

> not a lifetime achievement.

That would be those free to play clickers.

you're unable to comprehend why people have a long-term hobbies?
I actually got excited thinking it was play by mail but it was not. I was picturing weathered wax sealed letters arriving to your mailbox, written in an old school font, detailing outcomes of your decisions and how you wanted to proceed.
I think it would be really cool to run a game like that
Just get 20 hobbies like that to fill up each evening.