Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by abalashov 365 days ago
Only if you're a web economy weenie and think HTTP[S] is the measure of utility of most TCP interactions. ;)

I can't remember the last time I used telnet to test whether a web server was live. I don't think web servers figure very prominently in the work I do, though not zero, for sure. However, I doubt I'm the only one in that boat.
1 comments
charcircuit 365 days ago
Okay let's say you want to ping a Minecraft server and see how many users are online. That's not possible either with telnet.

The concept of protocols made up of printable characters delimited by new lines is antiquated.

link
abalashov 365 days ago
But that's not what I want to do. I just want to know if the listening socket is bound.
link
LambdaComplex 364 days ago
Alright, let's say you try doing that but it fails for some reason. Where did the failure occur? Were you able to open a TCP connection but you received garbage data that your minecraft-ping command didn't understand? Were you able to open a TCP connection but you received no reply to your ping? Did you fail to open a TCP connection (no SYNACK in response to your SYN)?

All of those problems have different root causes and therefore have different solutions. Telnet helps you figure out where in the stack the failure is occurring.

link