Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Herring 370 days ago
Apple's tune will completely change the second they get a leading LLM - Look at all the super important and useful things you can do with "Apple General Intelligence"!
2 comments

As someone who used to write academic ML papers, it's funny to me that people are treating this academic style paper written by a few Apple researchers as Apple's official company-wide stance, especially given the first author was an intern.

I suppose it's "fair" since it's published on the Apple website with the authors' Apple affiliations, but historically speaking, at least in ML where publication is relatively fast-paced and low-overhead, academic papers by small teams of individual researchers have in no way reflected the opinions of e.g. the executives of a large company. I would not be particularly surprised to see another team of Apple researchers publishing a paper in the coming weeks with the opposite take, for example.

The author is an intern, but they're also almost done with their PhD. They're not just any intern.
That's kind of expected for a research intern -- internships are most commonly done within 1-2 years before graduation. But in any case, the fact that the first author is an intern is just the cherry on top for me -- my comment would be the same modulo the "especially" remark if all the authors were full time research staff.
No, it wont. This comment essentially says science doesnt matter for anyone, only whether or not they're leading in marketing.
I think it's closer to saying that those who are falling behind declare that the science doesn't matter.
one hasnt fallen behind when those in "front" are on the wrong path
Perhaps, but that remains to be seen.

On the other hand future events have no bearing on what Herring was saying, only the accuracy of it.

I think the comment says science doesn't matter for Apple, specifically.