[mjevans]

Intuitively I knew this class of problem was theoretical only BS when it came up in college...

I hadn't considered that sort of strange effect though! Makes me feel not so bad for 'never really getting it' because I just couldn't wrap my mind around the problem description's obvious inanity and the infinite edges.

[aydyn]

The question is not pretending to be realistic. No one is thinking it is possible to build an infinite grid of resistors.

It's simply an evaluation of your mathematical ability to manipulate the equations and overall understanding of them, wrapped up in a cute little thought experiment. This evaluation IS relevant to more realistic scenarios and therefore your grade and engineering ability.