[zerd]

> it wasn't a widespread GCP outage.

If this wasn't widespread, what is?

Incident affecting API Gateway, Agent Assist, AlloyDB for PostgreSQL, Apigee, Apigee Edge Private Cloud, Apigee Edge Public Cloud, Apigee Hybrid, Cloud Data Fusion, Cloud Firestore, Cloud Logging, Cloud Memorystore, Cloud Monitoring, Cloud Run, Cloud Security Command Center, Cloud Shell, Cloud Spanner, Cloud Workstations, Contact Center AI Platform, Contact Center Insights, Data Catalog, Database Migration Service, Dataform, Dataplex, Dataproc Metastore, Datastream, Dialogflow CX, Dialogflow ES, Google App Engine, Google BigQuery, Google Cloud Bigtable, Google Cloud Composer, Google Cloud Console, Google Cloud DNS, Google Cloud Dataflow, Google Cloud Dataproc, Google Cloud Pub/Sub, Google Cloud SQL, Google Cloud Storage, Google Compute Engine, Identity Platform, Identity and Access Management, Looker Studio, Managed Service for Apache Kafka, Memorystore for Memcached, Memorystore for Redis, Memorystore for Redis Cluster, Persistent Disk, Personalized Service Health, Pub/Sub Lite, Speech-to-Text, Text-to-Speech, Vertex AI Search

[ikiris]

Our entire infra in GCP stayed up just fine, we just couldn't manage anything. IDK what to tell you. Many of the things you list here were not down at all.

[mirashii]

That it wasn’t down for you does not mean it wasn’t down for others or even almost everyone. Certainly, Google wouldn’t have listed the services as having an outage if nobody was impacted. You can’t extrapolate from “works for me” to “it must have been working for everyone”.

[ikiris]

Dude, I literally was an SRE there. I'm well aware of how this stuff works.

If some of those things listed had actual widespread outages, it would have been much much worse.

[solardev]

I don't understand your argument? Wasn't GCP's own status page calling them outages? Some of our upstream providers (who use GCP) were definitely affected and down.

As a former SRE there, is "widespread outage" a specific, special kind of classification that's not obvious to the public just by looking at the status page...? Or what do you mean?

[iimblack]

So weird to argue when google themselves listed these as having an outage.