Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by donnachangstein 372 days ago
Can you define "local network"? Probably not. Most large enterprises own publicly-routable IP space for internal use. Internal doesn't mean 192.168.0.0/24. foo.corp.example.com could resolve to 9.10.11.12 and still be local. What about IPv6? It's a nonsense argument fraught with corner cases.
4 comments
duskwuff 372 days ago
> Can you define "local network"?

Sure - a destination is "local" if your machine has a route to that IP which isn't via a gateway.

If your network is large enough that it consists of multiple routed network segments, and you don't have any ACLs between those segments, then yeah, you won't be fully protected by this browser feature. But you aren't protected right now either, so nothing's getting worse, it's just not getting better for your specific use case.

link
donnachangstein 372 days ago
> Sure - a destination is "local" if your machine has a route to that IP which isn't via a gateway.

Fantastic. Well, Google doesn't agree

The proposal defines it along RFC1918 address space boundaries. The spitballing back and forth in the GitHub issues about which imaginary TLDs they will or won't also consider "local" is absolutely horrifying.

link
account42 372 days ago
Cool so it will protect 99.999% of home networks. Compared to 0% which are protected now. Sounds great!
link
mystifyingpoi 372 days ago
Not to be snarky, but that's a good example of "perfect being the enemy of good". You are totally right that there are corner cases, sure. But that doesn't stop us from tackling the low hanging fruit first. Which is, as you say, localhost and LAN (if present).
link
eschaton 372 days ago
It should not even be able to communicate with the local network at all, it’s a goddamn web page. It should be restricted to just communicate with the server that hosts it and that’s it.
link
emushack 372 days ago
They define it the explainer this was originally based on: (https://github.com/WICG/private-network-access/blob/main/exp...)

Quote: We extend the RFC 1918 concept of private IP addresses to build a model of network privacy.

Concretely, there are 3 kinds of private network requests:

    public -> private
    public -> local
    private -> local
link