Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sorcerer-mar 384 days ago
In most democracies, you can literally go grab a clipboard and knock on doors and gather signatures to put your own name on the ballot.

Sure, power isn't evenly distributed and there are some obvious improvements we should pursue, but this does not a North Korea make
1 comments
impossiblefork 384 days ago
and it's not incredibly practical. Instead those sit at the head of institutions, whether political parties, governments, etc. have real power.

It's a bit like saying 'so make your own Facebook', but that's pretty useless if it's a response to someone who feel that some big social media company is influencing public discourse and harming proponents of certain ideas.

You can't make your own Facebook, or organize a political party other than in response to slow phenomena, and here we're talking about something has until recently been seen as literally illegal-- against the founding principles of the EU, so this is a huge, sudden change which people have no chance of resisting in a representative system.

link
sorcerer-mar 384 days ago
Completely normal people win political power all the time, at least in the US where I'm familiar with it.

No they don't get elected to the highest offices in the land (nor should they), but you can absolutely work your way there from a clipboard.

link
impossiblefork 383 days ago
That really isn't true.

You are basically chosen by parties and other entrenched organizations. New parties are very unusual.

However, none of that really matters. Democracy, laws, etc. don't make this kind of anti-privacy policy more legitimate. If you create a STASI, it doesn't matter if you do so democratically, and that really is what we are talking about.

With software on your phones controlled by others going through your stuff you have a beyond-STASI-surveillance level.

link