Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ggm 395 days ago
Extraordinary claims demand extraordinary evidence.

I totally hate the ontology of AI models. It's a constant for me: allowing these words to be come terms of art invites the mis-application of meaning into ordinary discourse.

Whatever it is they do, doing it less or more than humans isn't the point. They aren't humans, and its not a human behaviour, and trying to sneak it in as "like" is really a sin of commission: it's part of the message to make personhood assumed not tested.

Do people have rich fantasy life? Do they routinely mis-read and mis-hear, and mis-see? Sure! Thats what a mondegreen is. It's what a whole bunch of Insurance accident reports are: you literally didn't see the other car.

We functionally live inside a simulation of the world, created internally by the brain. we all know that. So at one level the CEO is being disingenuous.

I'm thinking about a carrot right now. it has a face. and hands. It's attached to the CEO of Anthropic in several entertaining ways. Does the carrot exist? No: it's a conceptual carrot. But I sure am thinking about it.

1 comments

Thanks for the insightful and engaging sharing. I believe that the human brain, along with our cognition and behaviour, is truly the most remarkable creation. The distinct boundaries between humans and AI should not be blurred.