Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Tuperoir 395 days ago
>knowledge of humanitites, science, technology, history, finance, and law, and be vetted with a background check filtering out criminal behavior, tax evasion, etc.

Who would remain ? What would be the incentive to train for this, besides money ?

1 comments

I'm not talking expert-professional-level knowledge.

Merely sufficient familiarity with the STEM, History, etc. to be able to pass undergrad distributive requirements. In this age, if you do not have a clue about how the scientific process actually works and basic concepts, and you don't understand the basics of how and why the country and it's constitution are built, you do not have any business writing the laws of the country. Too many current congress people couldn't pass these tests and it shows.

If we cannot, among a country of ~330 million, with 90+million with college education or above [0], find less then 20,000 [1] qualified and willing to fill state and national offices, we are pretty much doomed as a nation.

Even if we do something like include all 500k local offices, and then require prior local or state service to fill a national office, it should be a good selection.

OFC, if there is a problem, you can always increase the incentives (good idea) or lower the standards (bad idea). Since it is a temporary office, making the pay even more attractive than I mentioned above would be good -make it 95th-percentile or 115% of previous income to compensate for any inconvenience (e.g., a business owner who must vacate their position for 2yrs will likely have costs)

[0] https://www.census.gov/data/tables/2022/demo/educational-att...

[1] https://poliengine.com/blog/how-many-politicians-are-there-i...