[diggan]

> How can non-technical people tell what's "best"? You need to know what you're doing at this point, look for the right pitfalls, inspect everything in detail... this right here is the entire counter-argument for LLMs eliminating SWE jobs...

I'm not sure a tool that positions itself as a "programmer co-worker" is aiming to be useful to non-technical people. I've said it before, but I don't think LLMs currently are at the stage where they enable you to do things you have 0 experience in, but rather can help you speed up working through things you are familiar with. I think people who claim LLMs will completely replace jobs are hyping the technology without really understanding it.

For example, I'm a programmer, but never done any firmware flashing with UART before via a USB flasher. Today I managed to do that in 1-2 hours thanks to ChatGPT helping me out understanding how to do it. If I'd do it completely on my own, I'm sure it would have taken me at least the full day to do so, instead of the time it took. I was able to see when it got mislead, and could rewrite/redirect from there on, but someone with 0 programming experience, probably wouldn't have been able to.

[fragmede]

It depends on their setup and where they or the LLM gets stuck. If an experienced programmer is there to back them up, then a total beginner could totally make something. That is, given some familiarity with the terminal, specifically the know-how to setup a git repo on GitHub and clone it locally, and then setting up env keys and Aider, and the know-how to run npm I and npm run dev, a non programmer with some terminal skills someone is able to make simple games, purely by talking to Aider using the /voice command. When the LLM or they get stuck is when they'll need some backup from somebody with a decent amount of programming experience to get unstuck. Depending on what their doing though, it's entirely possible they won't get stuck until much further along in the dev process.