Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jackpirate 5050 days ago
But it could have been much worse, say like Chernobyl, and it wasn't due to good engineering.
2 comments

How could it have been like Chernobyl? The Fukushima reactors didn't have graphite moderators.

Totally different reactor technologies, equivocating them is spurious at best.

Using a totally different reactor technology strikes me as an example of good engineering.
The Chernobyl reactor also had no containment vessel, so the initial core failure blew a cloud of radioactive fire into the air. The Fukushima containment vessel kept most of the crap in one place until it could melt into a cohesive mass.
You wouldn't get the graphite fly ash that turned Chernobyl from a localized problem into an international headache, so no, it wouldn't have been as bad as Chernobyl. But it could have been much worse than it was.