Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mellosouls 393 days ago
Wolf Hall - originally a great adaptation of a superior book but the last series terribly constrained by budget and cliche background music.

Line of Duty - decent procedural but increasingly bonkers stories and hammy script/delivery.

Adolescence - well produced but liberal scare story. Netflix!

Haven't seen the others.

Hardly in the class of historical Beeb let alone contemporary US brilliance.

3 comments

>Wolf Hall ...

you're nitpicking. it's a high class, well-produced, well-acted, British-made TV show, by the BBC, of a very high quality that would be well-regarded in any era (if you ignore the weird racial thing they did in S2)

>Line of Duty

your opinion is absolutely in the minority, which isn't to say it's wrong, but it's a very well regarded, high class show that's widely seen as well above "decent procedural"

>Adolescence

whether it's liberal or paid for by Netflix is irrelevant to whether it's a high quality British-made tv show

>you haven't watched the others

then you're going to struggle to give a useful opinion on this matter, aren't you?

>Hardly in the class of historical Beeb

every historical BBC show you can name will have myriad minor subjective criticisms of the like you've just produced

>let alone contemporary US brilliance.

if you think US TV is even remotely comparable with UK TV, you're not paying attention. the US is long since out of its golden era, which pretty much died with Game of Thrones. US media has an order of magnitude more financial means than that of the UK, and yet what have they created of any real quality in the last few years besides White Lotus? they repeatedly fail to even remotely approach the class and quality of our TV. on the rare occasions they do get close, it's on the back of British actors or British production

> and yet what have they created of any real quality in the last few years besides White Lotus?

Now you’re just acting like the OP. There’s plenty of highly regarded us shows from the last few years. Just go look the highest rated current TV shows on rotten tomatoes.

well you're right. admittedly I haven't watched much recently besides White Lotus. on the other hand, it is true that most very highly regarded American shows have British actors in key roles, or creatives in production
... because American shows are where the most money and best scripts are, luring British talent there. I.e., the point of the discussion at hand.
most money, yes. best scripts, no.
I tried watching wolf hall because I love historical novels/shows, but I really struggled with it. Though I also struggled with the actual book so maybe it's something more fundamental.
Everyone dislikes some things. Not everyone likes classics such as Monty Python or Only Fools and Horses either. You're confusing "I don't like it" with "it's bad".
Confused? You've misread.

I didn't dislike any of them, all are fine at least; the first series of Wolf Hall is particularly good.