Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sReinwald 414 days ago
That's not quite correct. The "sovereignty" pitch here is largely illusory when dealing with a US-based company like OpenAI.

The US CLOUD Act (Clarifying Lawful Overseas Use of Data Act) explicitly gives US authorities the power to compel US-based companies to provide data stored on servers, regardless of where those servers are physically located. This effectively undermines any meaningful data sovereignty claims.

Consider the actual arrangement being proposed:

    - OpenAI (US company) maintains control of the infrastructure
    - OpenAI controls the models and their development
    - OpenAI maintains the security protocols and access rights
    - The data merely sits physically within national borders
This isn't sovereignty - it's a limited hosting arrangement that remains fully under US legal jurisdiction. US intelligence agencies can still access this data through legal mechanisms that bypass the host country's laws entirely.
1 comments

It would also allow OpenAI to operate in countries that have state subsidized electricity and low wages.