Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by stevenAthompson 415 days ago
> Someone photocopying a book to read on the toilet (and leave the original on their nightstand) isn't engaging in transformative use.

The situation you describe is more akin to "format shifting" or maybe "space shifting", which is converting copyrighted material to other formats or places as a backup, for preservation purposes, or just for convenience. It is legally protected in the US, and most of the rest of the world. I believe that was settled due to early litigation with VCR's, but there are mountains of relevant cases at this point.

I do recall reading that the UK recently changed their laws in that regard, and like most copyright law it can depend on the specifics of the situation and even (*yuck*) intent. So it's always worth checking if you're unsure.

1 comments

> It is legally protected in the US

Citation needed.