Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by iceron 5057 days ago
Affiliate tag? Not cool.
3 comments

I honestly think people that complain about referral link are just inherently negative. A free link, that takes you to a promotion, that saves you money, and you want to point out that the guy who brought this to your attention, is gaining something positive, at no expense to you or anyone. You probably pirated the book too.

Thanks OP, great deal and I bought it.

Regardless, this type of linking violates responsible FTC disclosure.

http://www.ftc.gov/os/2009/10/091005endorsementguidesfnnotic...

God forbid someone else make a small bit of money off a sale in exchange for promoting it!
I don't agree. Was glad to get notified about this bargain. IMHO this is what affiliate programs are for.
The problem is, once you start that on HN you'll have yet another reason for overposters to post every vaguely relevant special they see. I didn't mind that the poster did it (so bought via the referral) but it'd be sad if this caught on, and I wouldn't post a link with a referral myself. The benefits around here are karma, mutual respect and increased collective wisdom. Let's not find ways to dilute those further.
I agree that this is a potential problem but it is easily solved by the voting system. Low-quality submissions don't get much karma.